search:

Re: For Dr. Sam or anyone else ,RE:Kelp

From: Barbra (anonymous@obgyn.net)
Wed, 6 Feb 2002 01:17:27 -0600 (CST)


At Wed, 6 Feb 2002, Panacea wrote: >
>Just as long as it doesn't have iodine in it; and how would we find that
>out?
>

HI Panacea, I don't know how we would find that out,but I do assume that kelp contains a natural form of iodine. Here is the thing that boggles my mind. I know that normal,healthy individuals require 150mcg's of kelp per day. 1000mcg=1mg ,therefore,if I am taking 10 milligrams,that would be the equivilent of taking 10,000 mcg's of the kelp,which I think is way too high. On the contrary,most supplements contain 600mg's of kelp,so this leads me to believe that the amount that I am consuming,is not that high at all. Actually,we do tend to take more vitamins that what the body requires,if taking supplements. This seems to be a tough one for me to figure out,as the kelp,lethecin and apple cider vinegar diet was once thought to be a popular diet.

Also,you mentioned you take magnesium,

And while on the subject of magnesium..a mineral that I have been on for quite some time now...it does tend to reduce stomach acidity and is to always be taken WITH A MEAL..NEVER AFTER A MEAL OR ALONE.It neutralizes stomach acid,and then can bring on the diarrrhea.The absorbtion is much greater.Take with morning breakfast and with evening dinner. And another thing to mention while on the subject of supplements and our condition with PCOS....it is important that women who are not menestrating regularily,do not take extra iron supplements.Overload of iron is toxic and is one mineral that can store in the body and become toxic and also lead to Hemochromatosis.If you notice vitamins for women over the age of 50,don't usually contain much or any iron in them. If you are menestrating and especially if you are bleeding/flowing quite heavily,then it is advisable to take iron in your supplements.Then you are replacing what you have lost during menestrating. Men have more iron stores in their body than most women do,because most men tend to be heavier meat eaters.Another reason why they are usually more at risk for strokes and heart attacks than normal women who are menestrating.Ass menestrating women,we rid the excess iron via menestration. This was really a shock for me when my doctor first told me to stop the iron supplements,as my red blood cell count is fairly high,although I do menestrate regularily...they aren't as heavy as they normally should be.More scant and just heavier the second day of my onset,then by the fourth day,,it's all done.

I was told that with our condtion,it is always best to ask your doctor about adding additional supplements to your diet,as some can pose some dangers. This is why I am a little concerned about the Kelp.I have too many specialists,and some disagree with other's advice.I know my internist would be against the kelp for certain,but others would say it would pose some harm. I know I am actually making a big deal out of this,but I was feeling more antsy while on these neww vitamins.I gather too,that it is because they contain chromium +Vanadium(something I hate taking and have told my doc),so,I would gather he is still trying to get me to take something that has the latter two.

I actually never realized that you can have too much of a good thing. Motto is:less is more! Hard for me to practice what I preach,as I tend to overdo almost everything,hoping to find that Magic Bullet!

Take care and talk soon!=) (((hugs)))

>At Tue, 5 Feb 2002, Barbra wrote:
>>
>>Dear Doctor Sam,
>>
>>I hate to ask this silly question when I have the internet at my
>>disposal and also the A-okay from my doctor to be taking Kelp in my
>>multi vitamin,but I am a bit concerned about it.
>>
>>Since I have had problems and do have some problems with my
>>thyroid....is it wise to take a vitamin with 10mgs of kelp in it?
>>
>>I certainly don't like to question my doctor's advice on this vitamin
>>supplement that I have been taking,but would appreciate your advice.
>>
>>>From what he told me and from what I have read;kelp seems to have a
>>normalizing effect on the thyroid gland,thus making obese people lose
>>weight with it's use and thin people gain weight with it's use.As well
>>as it being very high in other trace elements and vitamins etc.
>>Do you think it is okay?
>>
>>Your advice would really be appreciated,as I really am afraid to go more
>>hyperthyroid again.
>>
>>--
>>Sincerely,
>>Barbra Camara
>>
>--
>Panacea
>

--
Sincerely,
Barbra Camara



recommended search...
Google
OBGYN.net forums endometriosis zone Web

use when must restrict search to only the pcos medication forum...
Enter search keywords:
Returns per screen: Require all keywords:
Return to [ PCOS Discussion Forums ] Technical Problems: webmaster@obgyn.net
Last Updated: Mon May 19 16:26:43 2008

home | medical professionals | women | industry | forums | international
e-mail | about us | advertising | our sponsors | contact us | disclaimer |

This information is provided for educational purposes only.
Please read the disclaimer. ©1996-2008, all rights reserved.
Do not reproduce without permission of MediSpecialty.com